I wrote last week about LeBron James’s over-the-top announcement show. Jim Gray, who interviewed James for the show, is not my favorite announcer. His self-interest comes through loud and clear in what he does, and he claimed in an interview with Charlie Rose last night that the program was his idea. Despite Gray’s lack of objectivity in the matter, he made one valid point. The owner of the Cleveland Cavaliers, Dan Gilbert, vented after James made his decision to leave Cleveland to join the Miami Heat, saying that LeBron was a traitor and that he had quit during the playoffs. Gray pointed out that Gilbert had not let that stop him from trying to sign LeBron, and he said the criticism was way over the top, something he had never seen before.
Then he hasn’t been looking. Burning bridges is becoming an art form in our society. I have not really figured out why this is so. Why are people so willing to sacrifice long-established relationships for the brief satisfaction of retaliating for a hurt?
Of course, many more people spend time on blogs (not this one) blowing off steam and accusing unseen others of having bad motives in their comments. They practice retaliation on people they don’t know without any readily discernible consequences. But this not only changes the quality of our discourse, it changes these people inside. The practiced emboldening enabled by the anonymous blog eventually laps over into conversations with people they know, and even people they love.
When the U.S. economy struggles, employer loyalty tends to wane. Layoffs lead to a generally suspicious tone in many workplaces, where employees no longer believe that management has their best interests at heart. Layoffs lead to accusations against the company, and those making the decisions. There are legitimate reasons to sue employers (including being fired as a retaliatory move for doing the right thing), but doing it just to make yourself feel better and make them miserable is a losing proposition.
Pennsylvania senator Arlen Specter is a poster child for bridge burning. However, his transparent reasons for switching parties did not win him great favor within the Democratic party, and he was not even able to survive his first primary contest running as a Democrat. I am pretty confident that he will not be recruited back by the Republicans.
Dan Gilbert’s response to LeBron’s abandonment seemed to be visceral, and not simply contrived, though I am guessing it will sell tickets and pump up season ticket holder loyalty. In fact, many Cleveland fans wrote in offering to pay part of his fine from the NBA for his comments. But he has burned a bridge with his former star, one it would have been hard to imagine him burning just a month or two ago. His temper tantrum will likely have permanent effects.
Perhaps the most devastating bridge burning I have seen has been in failing marriages, where one hurt is layered on top of the next. And it not only twists the characters of the vengeful parents, it leaves scars on the children that linger long after. I weep for those kids.
There may be bridges worth burning, but most are not. I have come within a word or two of doing it on occasion. In fact, in a few instances, I have likely said that word or two. But I am hard at work learning never to do it again.
I can say it is because life is too short for prolonged anger, and that is true. But, more importantly, in surrendering to the temptation to retaliate, I have allowed that other person to control who I am as a man. They have no right; only I can give it to them.
And it is my hope, in the inevitable day when my personal circumstances deteriorate because of someone else’s actions, that I will not give them that right.
Categories: Athletics
Mike, I find your comments spot on. I only have our country in mind when I say that we have, as a society, lost the ability to converse without ranco; that illusive statemanship is too rare now. Like you, I have enough of my own experiences of not exhibiting the behavior I yearn for. Also like you, I’m hard at work learning different responses to aggravation and injury.
Well stated, Mr. Shaub. I would like to add that gracious behavior has gone the way of the wooly mammoth. Combative and destructive behavior are currently an acceptable way to get what you want.; whether it is a promotion, winning a game or even purchasing wedding dress. It seems that the preferred method used to attract attention is extremism. Subtlety is a lost art. I do believe that eventually the scale will tip back and we will enter into a new age of civility. Maybe not in my lifetime, but then, I did not believe that someone like Mr. Obama would become president in my lifetime. Mr. Shaub, keep up the good work. You inspire us to take the high road and that at times that is not easy. Thank you.
Ms. Partridge, I’m appreciative of your work and thankful that you would take the time to comment.
My mom has always told me, “bitterness only eats the container in which it is held.” I agree with your statement that the only way to let someone have control of your emotions, is to give it to them. I personally feel the best way to live life is to “kill with kindness”, which in turn does not let others have the control they desire.
I also agree with the statements made about burning bridges. It is not worth it to sacrifice relationships in order to feel a sense of “retaliation”. When I think of burning bridges, I always associate it with people who are trying to get ahead (personal or professional) in their lives, and downplay relationships. Why do something if the end result will be to loose contact with people who care about you the most? I feel that life it way too short to make decisions based on short-term satisfaction, along with the risk loosing meaningful relationships. Being an honest parent, spouse, child, sibling and friend seems to be more important in the long run to me.
The examples used in the blog are dead right. I think that our society has become so self-absorbed and self-interested that individuals will go to great lengths to retaliate when there is no useful need for another’s thoughts or services. In LeBron’s case, Dan Gilbert saw no use of LeBron when he chose to go to Miami. As a result, he lashed out and cut all ties with him. Further, your illustration of divorce in our culture today highlights the effects on others when we do decide to act in self-interest and burn bridges.
Realizing that healthy long-term relationships will result in a more fulfilling life versus simply using people to attain short-term aspirations is so important– especially for young people. I know that this is an aspect of my life I am constantly striving to work on. We can become so wrapped up in our end goal, we don’t take time to look around and realize what is really important in our lives. We want to lash out and retaliate when in reality we should do the exact opposite.
Wow, the examples in this blog are nearly perfect as to what you are trying to convey to us as readers. I believe our society has gone down hill in tems of how selfish we have become. We seem to use people for only a single purpose and once that person is no longer needed they are discarded and nothing else is said or done about it. Gilbert lashed out only after Lebron had left and signed with the Heat and once that was done, there was no more use for him and he saw that he would more than likely never return to his home team. Granted it was not the smartest move and comments like that should be kept to themselves, but Lebron to me also acted in a selfish way.
Healthy long-term relationships are a good thing to have. Most of my closest friends I have had for over 20 years and I am only 23 now so you can see that I keep my friends close. I have had a couple of burnt bridges in my time, but it wasn’t so much as to what either of us have said, but more along the lines of certain actions that were taken. Each day I regret losing that person in my life. For a couple of others a burnt bridge could have been the best thing that has ever happend to me seeing as when we were friends they would just bring me down.
So, yes, I see as to what you are saying about burning bridges can have an negative connotation as to the general public can be more self interested in just themselves and not worry about what others have to think. Yes, divorce can be bad and I get sad for the children who have to suffer through it, but sometimes the buring of the bridge on that relationship is for the better and a healthier situation for everyone…A dear friend of mine, his parents are divorced and they get along better as friends living apart then when they were married. The burning of the bridges has to be looked at from all sides to get the real understanding of the problem
I believe that the idea of burned bridges is one that we, as auditors, have to be very mindful of. Because our society heavily promotes the notion of short-term satisfaction, many times in an instant of pain or hurt our most natural reaction is to retaliate. This is commonly done by so many who live with the mindset of, “ if it feels good now, do it” opposed to the trite, but true philosophy of always treating others the way you would like to be treated. This is a key concept that was promoted just last year during our recruiting by the various accounting firms. I remember constantly being warned not to burn bridges because you never know who you will end up working with 5, 10, or 20 years down the road.
However, when talking about burned bridges, I believe it is important also to focus on the aspect of forgiveness. While yes sometimes peoples words and actions can be so harsh as to consider them burned bridges, I believe many times those bridges can be mended when humility and forgiveness are shown by both parties.
First off, all during recruiting, it was stressed to us not to burn bridges during our time with the many different firms. Unfortunately, during my calls with various companies to turn down offers, many of the partners or managers were the individuals ruining the relationship we had created by keeping me on the phone for an hour or more to tell me how much I was going to regret the decision I was making. This has bothered me since that time, and I’ve wondered how it will end up turning out down the road if I ever encounter these people again.
However I had a great experience on this topic yesterday. I had to call a partner to tell him of my decision not to take a full time offer. I did so with caution, afraid that I would be yelled at for my choices. I was also not looking forward to the call because I really respect this person, both as a partner in the firm and as an individual and the way he lives his life. But, to my surprise, the conversation went extremely well. He did express his disappointment in my leaving the firm, but he was genuinely interested in hearing why I made the choice I did and learning if there was anything he could do better in the future. By being respectful and supportive, he actually made respect him even more. When I thanked him for the way the conversation went after an hour and a half of talking, he said he didn’t understand why anyone would throw away a good business relationship that has been built with a few minutes of yelling. I wish that more people had this approach, and I will definitely take that lesson with me as I venture into the world.
I have been guilty of burning bridges in the past. Now that I am a little older and have a better picture of how the world works, I don’t understand why anyone would want to burn bridges. A short relief of anger isn’t worth ruining a possible life long relationship. In a world where a lot of how successful you are is tied to who you know, almost no good comes from burning bridges. Even if someone isn’t your favorite person, being kind and professional to everyone you meet definitely will have long-term benefits.
Outside of the business world the same concepts apply. I personally won’t put any trust into a friend who runs around burning bridges with all of his/her friends. It says a lot about a person who can overcome a negative experience with someone. You have to be able to get over the fact that someone might have made a mistake in the relationship. I have had several instances where friends have done something that made me mad, but forgiveness is a much better route then hatred.
In the past I have burned a few bridges and found that in the long run it truly isn’t worth all the trouble just to get your few moments of satisfaction. I feel as though many times when bridges get burned it has been caused by both parties having unclear expectations from one another. Communication within any relationship is important and when strong can help avoid situations were bridges are burned. It is important to leave relationships on a good standing because you never know when you might run into that person again. Our decisions and our words have a strong impact on our relationships with others. I believe in the LeBron case Dan Gilbert felt betrayal and spoke out of anger. He was outraged after he had catered to LeBron and his demands. I believe as social media becomes more popular the amount of bridges getting burned in relationships will increase. With so many having access to multiple media outlets people are constantly updating others on their most recent opinions. People don’t always take the time to think about others and how they would perceive something. Many words and opinions can be misinterpreted using social media which can cause serious problems.
I believe few people truly intend to burn bridges, but that it occurs as a result of a lack of self control. The examples you mentioned make you realize the significance of controlling our emotions when things don’t go how we hoped. Few of the people you mentioned had reactions that were in their best interest. They were so quick to retaliate and go on the offensive that they lost control.
Dan Gilbert looked foolish reacting the way he did as an owner of a franchise. Throwing a temper tantrum and using all capital letters in an email are not effective ways to get your message across. Who could blame Lebron for leaving a team owned by someone who reacts like that? He may have won the support of some fans in the short term, but he also lost a lot of respect as a professional.
I liked how you used the LeBron/Gilbert example. I think professional sports provides us with the most public view of bridge burning. Sadly, dramatic examples like LeBron/Gilbert are not isolated to U.S. sports. Some of the most dramatic examples of bridge burning I’ve seen have been in England’s top flight soccer league, the English Premier League. An example that really sticks out to me is Liverpool FC selling their star forward Fernando Torres. Many fans knew that Torres wanted to leave Liverpool because the club was having a terrible season and were not likely to qualify for the competitions against the top clubs in Europe. Torres put in a transfer request at the end of the transfer window and was eventually sold to Chelsea FC. When the two clubs played against each other a few weeks later, the Liverpool supporters that had once idolized Torres now verbally abused and demonstrated against him.
To treat a player that had given his all to help the club for many years with such disrespect was really disheartening for me to see. Seeing behavior like this and the LeBron/Gilbert mess makes me wonder why the owners and fans can’t just say thanks for your service and good luck in the future? Why do these people have to vilify a player for making a decision to take a new path in their career, a decision that many of the fans do with their own careers?
The idea of burning bridges is one that’s been on my mind quite a bit over the past month or two, and my situation is relevant to countless others who have taken your classes. I struggled a lot with the decision to accept my full time offer after my internship, as many students do. I think during this process it’s easy to say to yourself, “I can accept this offer right now. It’s safe and nice to have a job before you graduate. Worst case scenario, if I find something I like more along the way, I’ll take that job and only burn a bridge with one firm.” I believe that thought crosses many of our minds, but as I worked through this minimester, I realized what selfish logic that is. This isn’t necessarily the example of burning bridges in a moment of anger that you discuss in this entry, but I think it’s the same selfish thought that drives both cases.
To reflect on your example, though, I almost lost a lifelong friend in a moment of anger and retaliation in high school. The time I spent refusing to talk to him was also time I lost being able to spend with him, and when I look back, it was more draining for me to carry that anger with me than to forgive him. Life is too short for that indeed. The point you make at the end of the entry hit home for me. Only I can give another the right to control who I am as a man. That’s something I will carry with me, and I thank you for your post.
I had to deal with this issue a lot of times. Mostly when I have been told by others that I need to cut relationship with certain people and i have always disagreed with that.
We meet so many people in the course of our life and not everybody is bound to be perfect. I have my weaknesses and so do you. You will be treated bad at times and your friends might even use you for a wrong purpose, but I believe in the power of open communication and forgiveness.
Just because you have been not been treated fair or the way you expected to be, its not a reason strong enough to burn bridges with those people. What if you communicate with them? What if you explain them what you would expect from them? What if you try to change them and impart a word of wisdom to them?
Maybe we will have fewer burned bridges.
I find this post to be very interesting. I remember I was on a social media site and stumbled upon the quote: “May the bridges I burn light the way”. I was so astonished by this type of thinking. I think that burning bridges can lead a person to being stuck on an island. Is it really worth being stranded with no way out? What I mean is, there may come a day when you need or want that person back. I realize that is a somewhat selfish way of thinking but it is realistic. To me, burning bridges is more harmful to yourself than others and once that bridge is gone all you’re left with is a pile of ashes.