Adaptive Project Management Improves Performance in Conflict Areas
Data from thousands of World Bank projects reveal when flexibility helps — and when it hurts.

A flexible approach to project management may improve performance in conflict areas, while producing different results in more stable environments.
Armed conflict disrupts project management: supply lines, staff safety, approvals, and government priorities. Yet thousands of public projects in health, education, and infrastructure must continue during crises and reconstruction.
This creates a challenge for project leaders: when situations shift, should they stick to the plan or change course? Andres F. Jola-Sanchez at Mays Business School at Texas A&M University studied the role of adaptability through a World Bank pilot that allowed projects to change direction during implementation.
The study finds that built-in adaptability helps projects perform better in conflict areas, but it can reduce performance in low- or non-conflict settings. In the data, weaker performance in stable environments is linked to weaker design quality, cost overruns, and overly optimistic plans. The benefits of adaptability also decline as projects become more complex.
Key Takeaways:
- Adaptive project management reduces the negative effects of conflict on project performance but does not always improve results in low- or non-conflict areas.
- In the World Bank’s pilot, adaptive projects outperformed traditional ones in conflict, especially with more experienced teams and focused projects.
- The advantage of adaptability diminishes as projects become more complex and span more development areas.
- In low- or non-conflict areas, adaptive projects performed worse relative to traditional ones. The data suggests this is due to weaker design quality, cost overruns, and overly optimistic plans.
- For leaders managing projects in unstable environments, the question is not whether to be flexible, but when flexibility helps and what makes it work.
Why Does Project Performance Drop in Conflict Areas?
Conflict lowers project performance by disrupting work and weakening institutions. In World Bank projects, governments are both beneficiaries and main administrators. When government capacity is stretched or priorities shift, projects can slow or stop.
In this study, conflict intensity is measured at the country level during a project using data on battle-related deaths. The results are clear: higher conflict intensity is associated with lower project performance ratings.
The paper also uses qualitative evidence from World Bank evaluation reports to show what “conflict disruption” looks like in practice, including:
- interruptions of project activities and logistics
- threats to personnel and resources
- government immobilization during political conflict
- delays and suspensions that affect timelines and delivery
In Bolivia, for example, an evaluation report notes that, “the government was largely immobilized by social and political conflict during much of the project implementation period and was unable to carry out the implementation.”
What “Adaptive Project Management” Means in This Paper
In this research, “adaptive project management” refers to the World Bank’s Adaptable Program Loan (APL) approach, used between 1998 and 2013. APL projects were designed in phases and explicitly built to incorporate learning and change, rather than staying fixed after initial approval.
The paper describes APLs as enabling three core capabilities:
- Piloting to test assumptions and fit
- Heavy monitoring, feedback, and learning
- Course correction within a project or across a series of linked phases
Simply put, adaptive projects are intentionally flexible, not just carefully planned from the start.
The paper gives concrete examples of how APL projects adapted during political instability, including restructuring project scope, shifting objectives, changing implementing partners, dropping components, reallocating funds, extending timelines, and temporarily suspending activities.
The Dataset: A Rare Look Across Thousands of Real Projects
The study draws on the full universe of World Bank projects during the APL pilot period:
- 4,834 total projects funded by the World Bank from 1998 to 2013
- 429 adaptive (APL) projects
- 4,405 non-adaptive (non-APL) projects
- projects across 92 countries and 25 development sectors
- approximately $55 billion in development resources
To measure project performance, the study uses the World Bank’s Independent Evaluation Group (IEG) performance ratings. This is a six-point scale from “highly unsatisfactory” to “highly satisfactory,” based on how well a project met its original goals.
To capture conflict conditions, the paper uses armed conflict data from the Uppsala Conflict Data Program, converting annual conflict intensity into an average level during each project’s implementation period.
Finally, the author supplements the quantitative analysis with a detailed reading of evaluation reports, focusing on 128 low-performing adaptive projects to identify recurring failure modes.
How the Analysis Works
The logic of the analysis is clear: compare how projects performed across different combinations of risk and design.
- Start with project performance ratings (the IEG outcome measure).
- Identify projects’ level of conflict exposure during implementation.
- Compare adaptive and non-adaptive projects while also considering other factors like design quality, monitoring quality, budget, duration, country conditions, sector, region, and year.
- Test how adaptability influences the relationship between conflict and performance, rather than assuming adaptability has the same effect everywhere.
The paper uses both linear regression and ordinal models and reports robustness checks that examine related issues, including political transitions, alternative measures of instability, and different estimation methods.
What the Study Finds: Adaptability Is Valuable, but Conditional
The key finding: being adaptive helps projects succeed in conflict but may hurt performance in stable situations.
1.) Conflict Hurts Performance
Without adaptive features, higher conflict intensity is associated with lower project performance. The effect is modest but still important, and is one of the bigger factors explaining project performance after design and monitoring quality.
2.) In Conflict Areas, Adaptive Projects Outperform Non-Adaptive Ones
In conflict areas, adaptive projects perform about 0.29 points higher on the six-point performance scale than non-adaptive projects in similar conflict environments.
The paper sees this as evidence that adaptive projects are better suited to unstable situations, where making changes and learning during the project can help address disruptions.
3.) Experience Strengthens the Benefit of Adaptability
Adaptive projects performed better in conflict settings when there was more prior experience in the country, measured as the number of earlier projects implemented before the focal project began.
Adaptability works best when teams and institutions have prior project experience to draw on.
The paper also points to a mechanism that matters for managers: adaptability can make performance information actionable. One evaluation example from Pakistan notes that, “flexibility can also aid in creating competition among the implementing agencies and thereby provide incentives for routing financing to the better-performing entities.”
4.) Complexity Weakens the Benefit of Adaptability
The paper measures project complexity by scope, the number of development areas a project covers. As the scope increases, the positive effects of adaptability diminish. In the author’s preferred specification, a one-unit increase in scope is associated with roughly a 0.12-point reduction in adaptive project performance.
Qualitative evidence supports this: having more goals and more people involved makes coordination harder, and frequent changes use more resources. One evaluation report warns that working with many ministries and agencies, “can lead to serious coordination problems and consequent implementation delays.”
5.) In Non-Conflict Areas, Adaptive Projects Underperform
In low- and non-conflict settings, adaptive projects do worse than non-adaptive ones.
The paper connects this to problems with project design and planning. In non-conflict areas, adaptive projects have lower design quality scores, and design quality is a strong predictor of performance. This suggests that weaker design quality helps explain why adaptive projects perform worse in low-conflict environments.
The Hidden Risk: Flexibility Can Invite Over-Optimism
A key contribution of the paper is explaining why adaptive projects may do worse in stable settings.
The author argues that adaptive projects can fall prey to the planning fallacy, in which planners underestimate costs and complexity and overestimate benefits. The paper suggests that adaptability might make this bias worse because teams may think they can fix problems later. The paper tests this idea using two indicators:
- Cost overruns: the gap between final costs and initial budgets
- Benefits overestimation: the gap between initially estimated economic rates of return and final estimates
Adaptive projects are, on average, more likely to exceed budgets and overestimate benefits than non-adaptive projects.
In practice, the warning is not that flexibility is bad, but that it can sometimes encourage weaker planning.
What This Means for Leaders Running Projects Under Uncertainty
This research connects project management, operations, and real-world work in unstable situations. For managers, the main lesson is to use adaptability as a tool, not as the standard approach for every project.
Based on what the study finds, three lessons stand out:
- Use adaptive project management when there is real instability. In conflict situations, adaptability can help offset the negative effects of conflict on performance.
- Combine adaptability with experience and learning systems. The benefits are greater when teams have more past project experience to rely on and when monitoring information is actually used to make changes.
- Keep adaptive projects focused. When projects span more areas, coordination costs rise, and it becomes harder to manage adaptability effectively.
These findings are directly relevant for leaders managing portfolios in fragile and conflict-affected states, humanitarian-development “nexus” operations, and reconstruction efforts after large-scale disasters.
What the Study Does Not Claim
This is an observational study that uses past project data and evaluation ratings, not a controlled experiment. The findings show strong links and consistent patterns, but the paper does not claim that just making a project adaptive will always improve performance.
The paper also notes boundaries on generalization:
- It studies the World Bank’s APL instrument (1998–2013), which was later discontinued and replaced by a different approach (MPA), for which evaluation data are not yet available in the paper.
- It focuses on state-based armed conflict intensity at the country level; the author encourages future work on other forms of violence and uncertainty.
- It cautions against applying the results outside the prosocial sector without care.
“Prosocial Project Management in Conflict Areas” is published in Production and Operations Management.
FAQs / Implications
What is adaptive project management?
Adaptive project management is an approach that emphasizes flexibility, continuous learning, and iterative adjustment throughout a project’s lifecycle, rather than following a rigid, pre-defined plan.
Does adaptive project management improve project performance in conflict areas?
Yes, in this study, adaptive projects performed better than non-adaptive projects in conflict areas, and adaptability helped counteract the conflict’s negative effect on performance. The paper measures performance using World Bank evaluation ratings and reports this pattern after controlling for project and country factors.
Why do adaptive projects sometimes perform worse in non-conflict areas?
Adaptive projects underperformed in low- and non-conflict areas in this dataset, and the paper links that pattern to weaker project design quality and planning problems. The author also finds evidence consistent with the planning fallacy: adaptive projects are more prone to cost overruns and overestimated benefits.
What makes adaptive project management more effective during conflict?
Adaptability is more effective in conflict settings when it is reinforced by experience and learning. In the paper, adaptive projects benefited more when the country had a larger stock of prior project experience, suggesting that teams and institutions learn to course-correct more effectively over time.
How does project complexity affect adaptive project management?
Project complexity reduces the benefit of adaptability. The paper measures complexity using project scope (the number of development areas covered) and finds that as scope increases, adaptive projects’ performance declines. Evaluation reports suggest that coordination and administrative burden increase as more agencies and objectives are involved.
Featured Researcher
Research Driving Real-World Impact
Discover faculty research and insights shaping leadership, business, technology, and society.
